On Friday, January 22, 2016, Senator Joe Schiavoni (D-Boardman) and State Representative John Boccieri (D-Poland) sent the following letter to Craig Butler - Director of the Ohio EPA - requesting additional information related to Sebring, Ohio, water quality concerns.  


Dear Director Butler,

We are writing to address the delayed response to signs of elevated lead levels in Sebring and Beloit’s drinking water, as described to us in a call with Ohio EPA at 10:15 PM on January 21, 2016. Although the tests revealing lead contamination were conducted in August and September of 2015, this information was just recently made public and brought to our attention. It is therefore possible that residents in the affected areas have unknowingly been drinking water that poses threats to their health.

We would like to assist in distribution of accurate information to the public and ensure that proper action is being taken to rectify this situation and prevent similar incidents in the future. We request that you provide us with additional information as detailed below.

Below is listed a timeline of events based on a call with Ohio EPA this morning. Please verify or correct the following information.

  • August 2015: Samples are collected from within the Sebring water supply pursuant to triennial testing
    • Questions:
      • When did testing last take place prior to August 2015?  What were the results of those tests?
      • How many samples were taken in August 2015?  What was the range for the 2015 testing?
  • October 10, 2015: Ohio EPA was informed that lead levels had exceeded government-regulated action levels
    • Question:
      • Is this the correct date?
      • When did the water system know of the exceedance?
  • November 10, 2015: The 30-day deadline by which the tested households should have received results
    • Question:
      • Again, is this the right date, or did the system have the results and the obligation to share them earlier?
  • December 10, 2015: The deadline for the water system to have completed the notification and public education required by rule 3745-81-85
  • December 20, 2015: The deadline for the water system to have reported to Ohio EPA the documentation of the communication and public education efforts under rule 3745-81-90
  • January 21, 2016: Ohio EPA issues three violations, which triggered notification to the public
    • Questions:
      • Can you provide documentation detailing the violations?
      • When did Ohio EPA staff start providing on-the-ground assistance in the community?
      • When were ODH and local health/emergency management notified, and when did they begin providing water or setting up lead testing options?

Additional Questions:

  • Does Ohio EPA have a standard additional waiting period after a violation is triggered? Why the delay between the deadlines and the issuance of violations?
  • Is there any rule that prevents Ohio EPA from directly notifying the public - especially if a local system has missed deadlines?
  • What is the breakdown by which water systems are required to report every six months vs. annually vs. triennially? 
  • How many places in Ohio are under current public education requirements due to government action level exceedance?
  • How many places in Ohio are only required to report every year or every three years, based on previous test results, as was the case in Sebring?
  • How many homes in Ohio have pipes that would be susceptible to this type of corrosion?
  • When will public information be available on the testing taking place now?
  • What resources are available to residents who may be concerned about elevated lead levels?

Thank you for your prompt attention to this critical matter. We urge you to take swift action to remedy this situation for the at-risk residents of Sebring and Beloit.



State Senator                     State Representative

33rd Senate District            59th House District                                              


Related Content

Featured Posts

Senate Democrats Lauch Statewide Tour Of Ohio Schools


COLUMBUS - Senate Minority Leader Joe Schiavoni (D-Boardman) and members of the Senate Democratic Caucus have launched a series of trips around the state to gather opinions from parents and educators on ways to improve education in Ohio.


Senator Schiavoni Comments On Governor's Decision To Strip Worker's Collective Bargaining Rights


Columbus—Senate Minority Leader Joe Schiavoni (D-Boardman) released the following statement after Governor Kasich rescinded an executive order that granted collective bargaining rights to home healthcare and childcare providers: 


Leader Schiavoni Honors Local Heroes With Memorial Highway


Minority Leader Joe Schiavoni (D-Boardman) has worked over the last few months to pass legislation that would dedicate a portion of I-80 in Austintown in honor of two local Vietnam Veterans as the "Marine Sergeant James Prommersberger and Army Second Lieutenant Charles W. Brown Memorial Highway". This summer, these efforts will become a reality. 


Senate And House Democrats Call On Governor To Halt Closure Of State Developmental Centers


Columbus –State Senate Minority Leader Joe Schiavoni (D-Boardman), Senator Capri S. Cafaro (D-Hubbard), State Representative Ron Gerberry (D-Austintown) and State Representative Michele Lepore-Hagan (D-Youngstown) sent a letter to Governor Kasich this week urging him to postpone the transfer of residents from the Youngstown and Montgomery Development Centers.  The four Mahoning Valley legislators have sponsored legislation to establish a State Facilities Closure Review Commission to determine if the facilities should remain open.